Councilman-elect Smith says tax money should be diverted from western end of city to help fire-ruined eastern end
Danny Smith, who lost his home in the fire, split from Silverstein and Stewart over a proposed disaster zone that could borrow over $115 million. And an Eastern Malibu resident wants taxpayers to provide "basic city services" like concrete walls and sewage lines to allow rebuilding on oceanfront lots.
By Hans Laetz
Incoming City Councilmember Danny Smith did not take long to disagree with two of his fellow councilmembers on a key issue. He spoke at the City Council meeting Monday night as a private citizen.
Last week we told you that Councilmembers Silverstein and Stewart were deeply skeptical of a proposal for a Malibu disaster zone tax district. That district would borrow money to pay for fire safety improvements in eastern Malibu's fire zone.
The bonds would be paid back with increased property tax revenue in years down the road.
The two councilmembers called it an unwise mortgage plan.
The new councilman, however, is a fire victim — he lost his house in the fire. Smith, the councilmember-elect from eastern Malibu, noted that the tax district might take some money from the central and western parts of the city.
Smith said: "This will earmark money to eastern Malibu that might otherwise be part of the general pool, the general fund. It's true.
"But these are infrastructure projects that we will need.
"And when central Malibu is hit or western Malibu is hit, we should support their own disaster recovery district to pay for their own infrastructure needs at that time.
"We are one city and we have to take care of each other."
If the tax district were set up, two out of the five board members would be from outside Malibu, from the L.A. County government. But Malibu would still control the list of what projects could be borrowed against.
More than $115 million could be borrowed for road repair and water tanks.
Caltrans has already told dozens of property owners along the beach they are in charge of paying to make sure the Pacific Coast Highway does not fall across their vacant lots into the ocean.
Tony Canzoneri, who lives in the fire zone and whose house was not destroyed, told the council that tax money be spent to install concrete bulkheads and a sewer line so that his neighborhood on the beach can rebuild.
He called those pricey items "basic city services."
Beachfront homeowners who lost their houses cannot afford to pay to build concrete supports that Caltrans hold them responsible for, to prevent PCH from falling across their burned-out lots into the ocean.
"If you want them to rebuild, you've got to recognize that somebody needs to go to Caltrans and say 'you have to hold the highway up.'
"That's one," he said.
He also said Malibu will lose out on future tax revenue from rebuilt houses if the families that own them cannot afford to build a sewer line. That is commonly viewed as essential if each lot owner can avoid installing very-costly bulkheads to protect individual sewage treatment plants.
"The next step is you've got the cost of sewage treatment on site, and seawalls. Those are public improvements. Those are traditional public infrastructure."
Canzoneri wants the public to pay for those improvements in front of the beachfront houses that burned down. "
They're underinsured. They can't afford to rebuild," Canzoneri asserted before the city council. "The point of this legislation is to create tax increment that you'd never get otherwise.
"If people don't rebuild, you won't get that increment, so you're giving nothing away.
Councilman Doug Stewart still feels it is a bad idea to borrow against future tax revenues. He noted the list of eligible projects was drawn up by L.A. County.
"I just want to be clear — every project that was given as an example, and I disagree with Tony, this is a list that came to us from the county.
" And I'll just pick on one. Water District 29 wants a water tank. Water District 29 raised our water rates 30% to pay for water tanks and infrastructure.
"So what you would be doing is taking our general fund income and diverting it to subsidize the water district, who is looking for other places to raise money."
Lame-duck councilmember Marianne Riggins was also skeptical.
"I'm kind of inclined to leave it to any future revenues that are going to come from increased property values here locally at the council hands, and let the councilmembers that are elected create capital improvement projects that the whole community wants.
"I think that limiting it to just one area that's been ravaged by disaster is kind of short thinking. We really should be thinking about things that are going to benefit the entire community, not just one particular area."
Danny Smith, who favors the tax district, lives in the proposed tax district — an apparent conflict of interest. He may not be able to vote on the issue when it comes back before the city council.
A final decision was put off until after he is sworn in in January.

Comments (1)
"Canzoneri (who lives in the fire zone) wants the public to pay for those improvements in front of the beachfront houses that burned down. " They're underinsured. They can't afford to rebuild," So the public is to pay for multi-millionaires who chose to be under-insured?? Can't afford to rebuild, but received insurance $$$ and can sell for $$$$$$. But public is to pay? REAL math examples needed, as this is too fuzzy.