Malibu.FM

Presented by KBUU 99.1 in partnership with The DiPaola Foundation

Judge removes top LA federal prosecutor as Palisades Fire retrial unfolds

A ruling that Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving could affect 5,000 criminal cases, including the retrial of Jonathan Rinderknecht.

By Hans Laetz

A federal judge is removing Bill Essayli as the top federal prosecutor for the Central District of California down in Los Angeles. This comes as that office has stumbled badly in their prosecution of Jonathan Rinderknecht, the man accused of causing the Palisades Fire. That blaze killed 12 people as it ripped into Pacific Palisades and Malibu two years ago.

Essayli is the political appointment who is overseeing the second trial for Rinderknecht. The first trial was botched and ended in a mistrial last summer. Confusion is reported in the LA federal prosecutor's office. Many top staff have been fired or resigned after Essayli's arrival. A federal judge Sunday ruled that Essayli is unlawfully serving as the top federal prosecutor in the Los Angeles office. That's because the U.S. Senate has rejected him twice. This decision potentially affects 5,000 criminal cases in LA.

The retrial Sunday descended into some chaos. Defense attorneys tried to have the jury hear testimony from a retired California firefighter. This witness claims that he saw on video from a drone a brown stain on a driveway near the point of origin for the fire. He claims that's a sign that fireworks could have ignited the deadly blaze, instead of Rinderknecht with a lighter. The federal prosecutors immediately pushed back against that. The judge emptied the courtroom Sunday to examine this so-called evidence. The trial resumes Monday.

Report typo or corrections