Malibu.FM

Presented by KBUU 99.1 in partnership with The DiPaola Foundation

SCE's own data shows October Malibu blackout wasn't justified

Southern California Edison says its multi-day October outage was warranted, but its filing shows actual winds were far below the company's trigger.

By Hans Laetz

Southern California Edison says it can prove that the multi-day power outage it imposed on Malibu last month was worth it.

But the company's own data shows that SCE shut off the power to Malibu based on a company weather forecast that missed by a mile.

SCE data shows that the actual wind gusts that week were only two-thirds the strength necessary to meet the company's very low trigger for turning off power in Malibu.

On Friday afternoon, the power company issued its mandatory intentional power outage report. It must file those within a month after an outage, as required by the California Public Utilities Commission.

In the report, the power company is required to justify its decision to preemptively endanger public safety by turning off the power.

Although turning off the power prevents lines from causing fires in the winds, it also endangers the public by blacking out traffic lights, turning off cell phone towers, affecting some Internet signals and other things that can endanger public safety.

Surprise — SCE in its report says it was justified.

But a look at its own data shows that the wind gusts were far below the triggers that SCE itself requires to kill the power across Malibu and across all of Southern California.

Roughly 327,000 customers were notified that their power might get shut off in mid-October. Forty-five percent of those houses and businesses actually got blacked out, including most of Malibu.

In its review, SCE says the actual measured wind speeds that week were 62 mph sustained with gusts up to 83. Well, that may have happened at some mountaintop somewhere in the Sierra Nevada or somewhere else in California, but no winds like that happened anywhere near Malibu.

Here in Malibu, the report reveals that SCE's predictions of wind speeds were way too high. The actual wind speeds clocked at that time were far below the trigger points set by SCE for killing the power.

For example, the threshold for turning off the power on the Cuthbert Circuit in the Paradise Cove area is winds of 28 mph. The SCE weather team predicted gusts of 33 mph that weekend.

But the actual peak winds were 19 mph, the speed of afternoon breezes that we commonly get most afternoons. That windspeed is only two-thirds as strong as the company's own very low threshold to trigger a power outage.

In its report, SCE says it was acting based on weather forecasts for gusts up to 70 mph. Well, the private weathercasters working for SCE may have come up with that forecast, but the National Weather Service forecast was far, far below that.

In fact, on Oct. 23, at the height of the so-called Santa Anas, the National Weather Service was predicting peak wind gusts of 25 mph in Malibu — not 70.

The SCE report runs hundreds of pages, most of which is boilerplate language that it copies and pastes over after every wind outage. In it, SCE says: "SCE recognizes that blackouts pose significant challenges and hardships for our customers.

"For this event, the results of the risk-versus-benefit comparison tool supported SCE's decision to turn off the power. All circuits that were turned off during this event had a benefit-to-risk ratio greater than one.

"Thus, the estimated benefit of the outage outweighed the estimated risk for this event."

The CPUC report by SCE was issued late Friday afternoon, too late in the day to get any specific SCE responses.

We'll make an effort on that Monday morning.

Report typo or corrections

Comments (0)· Be the first to comment.